5 Reasons to Applaud Hobby Lobby's Victory
Washington DC - National Center for Public Policy Research Chairman Amy Ridenour has issued the following statement regarding the Supreme Court's decision today in Burwell (formerly Sebelius) v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc. and Conestoga Wood Specialties Corp. v. Burwell to strike down ObamaCare's HHS contraception mandate and uphold an employer's right not to be forced to provide birth control and early abortion drugs and devices to employees against their conscience(s):
Today's decision was a victory for freedom, because a person who does not have the right to order his or her professional and personal life in accordance with his or her religious beliefs does not have freedom at all.
Supporters of the mandate who claimed incorporated businesses cannot exercise religion ignore that corporations are directed by human beings, and nothing in the act of incorporating strips away the humanity of business owners. There are many examples of businesses being operated under the constraints of their owners' religious beliefs. Chik-Fil-A forgoes significant profit by closing every Sunday for religious reasons, for example. If it were not possible for a corporation to exercise religious beliefs, Chik-Fil-A would be open on Sundays.
There are five key reasons Americans - women, men, liberals, conservatives, religious, atheists, users of birth control and non-users, should celebrate the Hobby Lobby decision today: freedom, finances, privacy, equality and the Constitution.
If you believe birth control or abortion is morally wrong, you shouldn't have to buy it for others just because you offered them a job. Under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, the federal government can only force people to violate their religious beliefs if the government has an extremely important reason for doing so and the government cannot accomplish its goals in any less restrictive way. It is debatable whether the provision of birth control and early abortion drugs and devices is even a function of the federal government, but even if that is to be so, clearly there are other ways of distributing these easily-accessible, inexpensive drugs and devices without forcing the involvement of religious employers.
Employees and employers should have the legal right to negotiate the pay packages that work best for them. If an employee would rather be paid in cold hard cash than birth control, the federal government has no moral right to tell her she cannot negotiate such terms. Cash can buy birth control, if that is desired by the employee. It can also buy groceries. Some employees prefer groceries.
Bosses don't belong in bedrooms, and ObamaCare's insistence on forcing employers to pay for birth control puts employers there - and the federal government in there with them. Employees have the right to close their bedroom doors. Nothing about this case has been more nonsensical than supporters of the contraception mandate claiming that employers who don't want to be involved in their employees' birth control are somehow meddling in their employees' personal lives.
As Obama Administration's Federal Register makes clear, the birth control mandate was never about helping low income women afford birth control: It was about enhancing the power and financial position of women relative to that of men. It is not the proper role of the federal government to try to help one group of Americans versus another. The government should stand for equality of opportunity, not sexism.
Americans have a First Amendment right to freedom of religion. Whenever this right is upheld, it is strengthened.
Ridenour has written the following on the Hobby Lobby case and HHS birth control mandate: "A Quick Guide to ObamaCare's HHS Contraceptive Mandate and Why the Supreme Court Should (and Will) Throw It Out" (March 2014), "Hobby Lobby's Court Victory in HHS Mandate Case is a Victory for Religious and Economic Freedom: Claims of an "Attack on Women who Use Birth Control" are Foolish Leftist Spin," (July 2013), "9 Takeaways from the Hobby Lobby HHS Contraception Mandate Oral Arguments " (March 2014), "How Can Senator Patty Murray Be So Ignorant about a Law She Voted For?" (March 2014), "White House Birth Control Statistics Don't Add Up" (Feb. 2012), "Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz Tells Four Lies in One Sentence, Washington Post Grades Two Pinocchios" (April 2014), "Democrat Congresswomen Walk Out of HHS Mandate Hearing to Protest Omission of Witness Who Wanted to Talk About Something Else Entirely" (February 2012), "Catholic Bishops Cannot Accept White House 'Compromise' on Birth Control Without Surrendering Principles" (Feb. 2012), "16 Seconds To Understanding the HHS Birth Control Mandate" (Oct. 2012), "Should Conservatives Choose HHS Mandate, Climate Change Positions Based on What is Likely to Win the Most Votes? " (March 2014)," "Would Jesus Pay for Abortions?" (Feb. 2012)," and "Obama Compromise Infringement of the First Amendment is Still Unconstitutional" (Feb. 2012).
In addition, an op-ed by Ridenour about the case ran in 45 newspapers across the United States in January and she has discussed the issue on several dozen radio programs.
The National Center for Public Policy Research, founded in 1982, is a non-partisan, free-market, independent conservative think-tank. Ninety-four percent of its support comes from individuals, three percent from foundations, and three percent from corporations. It receives over 350,000 individual contributions a year from over 96,000 active recent contributors.
- Congressman Condemns Supreme Court Decision in Hobby Lobby Case (Monday, June 30, 2014)
Dr. Ami Bera: "I'm extremely disappointed with the Supreme Court's decision in the Hobby Lobby case this morning, which sets a dangerous precedent of putting employers in charge of their employees'
Print This Article
Placer County News HeadlinesCalifornia Would Create More Jobs Without Prop 30In his recent piece for The Sacramento Bee, "State's job growth defies predictions after tax increases," David Cay Johnston argues that California's recent job creation numbers prove
Sacramento County Opposes Bay Delta Conservation PlanThis week the Sacramento County Board of Supervisors formally submitted comments challenging the findings of the Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) state environmental
Roseville to Host Senior Softball Western National ChampionshipsRoseville will play host this August to the Senior Softball Western National Championships
Roseville Crime Report Digest Update (7.29.14)Roseville, CA - The Roseville Police Department weekly crime report digest update for July 29, 2014.
Different Standards From Mortgage LendersJulie Jalone of MagnumOne Realty in Roseville, reports on a recent Fannie Mae survey which indicates there may be a growing difference in credit standards between small and large lenders. Which do you think has the tighter credit standards? Check out Julie's article and find out.
PCWA Comments on Bay Delta Conservation PlanDrought Watch: PCWA expresses concern about future water supply reliability for Placer County and claims EIR fails to consider key issues.
Honor Bowl Games at Del Oro August 2014ROCKLIN, CA. - William Jessup University announced today that it will serve as a sponsor for the Northern and Southern California 2014 Honor Bowl football games.
Tahoe Bike Classic Sept. 27 & 28The inaugural Tahoe Bike Classic will take over the Lake Tahoe basin this fall, September 27 & 28, 2014.
Lake Tahoe Marathon Returns September 14thArguably the most beautiful marathon in the world, the Lake Tahoe Marathon returns to Lake Tahoe on Sunday September 14, 2014. Since its inception in 1995, the Lake Tahoe Marathon has evolved into a premier running event
3 Month Old Dies in Sacramento, Parents JailedAshleigh Smith and the 19-year-old father, Terry Scott, were interviewed, they were both booked that night into the Sacramento County Jail on felony child abuse/neglect charges.
Dropping Gas Prices Lift Summer DriversLocal gas prices continue to drop and bring relief to drivers across California and the nation.
Inter-Faith Task Force Seeks New MembersThe Roseville Police Department is hosting an Inter-Faith Task Force comprised of congregational leaders and security teams for churches and other