Study: CT Scans Carry Cancer Risk for Young Patients
(SACRAMENTO, Calif.) -- A nationwide study of more than 40,000 children evaluated in hospital emergency departments for head trauma found that if children had only loss of consciousness, and no other signs or symptoms related to the head trauma, they are very unlikely to have sustained serious brain injuries. Children who have only isolated loss of consciousness after head trauma do not routinely require computed tomography (CT) scans of the head, reported researchers from UC Davis Health System and Boston Children's Hospital.
Although CT scans are the standard way to determine if a child has life-threatening bleeding in the brain that may necessitate surgical intervention, the radiation involved carries a small but quantifiable long-term risk of cancer. As such, the data indicates CT evaluation for children with head trauma should not be routinely used if they are at low risk for clinically significant traumatic brain injuries.
The findings were published today in the journal JAMA Pediatrics in an article titled "Isolated loss of consciousness in children with minor blunt head trauma."
"Fear of missing a clinically significant head injury, and the wide availability of CT scanners, have been the main factors driving an increase in the use of CT imaging over the past two decades," said Nathan Kuppermann, professor and chair of the UC Davis Department of Emergency Medicine, and principal investigator of the original study from which the data and current analysis of head injuries were derived. "Our findings can help doctors confidently make a decision to forego CT testing when their patients are unlikely to benefit from it, enabling physicians to first observe their patients for a period of time before deciding on CT use."
Whether the presence of a single factor suggestive of brain injury is reason enough to justify obtaining a CT scan has been a question Kuppermann and colleagues with the Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network (PECARN) have been actively exploring through a series of studies over the past few years. The current study found that children who lost consciousness after head trauma, but then were awake and alert in the emergency department, and had none of the other five factors determined important by PECARN guidelines for identifying children at low risk for clinically significant brain injuries after head trauma (called the PECARN traumatic brain injury prediction rules), had a very low rate of clinically important brain injuries -- only 0.5 percent, or 1 in 200 children.
If a child had isolated loss of consciousness without any other signs or symptoms of head trauma (i.e., including factors outside of the PECARN traumatic brain injury prediction rules), the incidence of an important brain injury dropped to only 0.2 percent, or 1 in 500 children. Furthermore, the duration of the loss of consciousness did not significantly affect risk.
"Children with clinically important brain injuries rarely have loss of consciousness alone, and almost always present other symptoms, such as vomiting or showing signs of neurological problems," said Lois K. Lee, lead author of the current study and director of trauma research at Boston Children's Hospital. "Being able to make treatment decisions backed by strong data helps doctors and parents feel better about deciding whether further testing is really needed."
Lee added that in cases in which a parent or physician is uneasy about a child's condition, it would be reasonable to observe the child in the emergency department for a few hours to see if any other signs or symptoms arise before making the decision whether to have a CT.
Studies show that exposure to the ionizing radiation associated with CT scans increases the risk of cancer. According to "The Essential Physics of Medical Imaging," one head CT scan for a child - based on a youngster's age - is the equivalent of approximately 140 chest x-rays. Radiation exposure in the brains of developing children is of particular concern and must be weighed carefully against the risk of traumatic brain injury that could cause permanent damage or death if not identified early. Lee and Kuppermann noted that if the guidelines are applied appropriately, the use of unnecessary CT scans could be significantly reduced.
An earlier, landmark study led by Kuppermann and published by The Lancet in 2009 developed and validated a traumatic brain injury prediction rule to identify children at low risk for clinically important head injuries who probably do not require CT evaluation. Factors in the rule included abnormal mental status, scalp hematoma (a large swelling on the scalp in children younger than 2 years old), evidence of a skull fracture, vomiting, history of loss of consciousness associated with the head trauma, and severity of the injury mechanism (such as a fall from a height or a car crash that killed other passengers). If a child with head trauma has none of the six associated factors, researchers determined that a CT scan would be very unlikely to reveal a clinically significant problem, making it unnecessary for a child to undergo the CT scan.
Two related studies led by Kuppermann and his team were recently published in the Annals of Emergency Medicine. One, in the June 2014 issue, examined whether vomiting alone warrants a CT scan in children who have acute head trauma ("Association of traumatic brain injuries with vomiting in children with blunt head trauma"). The second, in the March 2014 issue, evaluated whether swelling of the scalp in children younger than 2 years old, as a result of a head trauma by itself, warrants a CT scan ("Risk of traumatic brain injuries in children younger than 24 months with isolated scalp hematomas"). Both studies determined that the presence of these individual factors alone, with no other signs and symptoms of head trauma, were not sufficient to justify an immediate CT scan. Rather, the researchers said that children in these cases should be observed for a period of time before any decisions regarding CT use are made.
"Head trauma in children results in nearly half-a-million visits to U.S. emergency departments annually," said Peter Dayan, lead author of both recent studies and an associate professor of pediatrics at Columbia University in New York. "Our research provides important support for frontline doctors to help them avoid unnecessarily exposing children to the radiation risks inherent in CT testing."
The head trauma study was designed by Kuppermann and colleagues in PECARN to determine which children evaluated in the emergency department for head trauma are at low risk for clinically significant traumatic brain injuries and who do not require cranial CT evaluation. The pediatric research network comprises 18 hospital emergency departments across the nation and serves more than 1.2 million children. The enormous amount of data generated by this patient population enables investigators to answer questions about best practices with a high degree of confidence.
Other authors of the JAMA Pediatrics study evaluating isolated loss of consciousness were James Holmes, UC Davis School of Medicine; David Monroe, Howard County General Hospital; Michael Bachman, Newark Beth Israel Medical Center; Todd Glass, now at Nemours Children's Hospital; Prashant Mahajan, Wayne State University School of Medicine; Arthur Cooper, Columbia University Medical Center at Harlem Hospital; Rachel Stanley, University of Michigan School of Medicine; and Michelle Miskin, University of Utah.
The study was supported by a grant from the U.S. Health Resources and Services Administration/Maternal and Child Health Bureau Division of Research, Education and Training, and the Emergency Medical Services for Children Program.
UC Davis Health System is improving lives and transforming health care by providing excellent patient care, conducting groundbreaking research, fostering innovative, interprofessional education, and creating dynamic, productive partnerships with the community. The academic health system includes one of the country's best medical schools, a 619-bed acute-care teaching hospital, a 1,000-member physician's practice group and the Betty Irene Moore School of Nursing. For more information, visit http://healthsystem.ucdavis.edu.
Pet Care | Real Estate | Restaurants | Tech | View All | * Add/Upgrade Business
Placer County News HeadlinesSmart & Final in Roseville to Occupy Wise Buys SpotRoseville, CA -- Smart & Final, a non-membership warehouse grocery store is preparing to open shop at 1159 Roseville Square, which was previously home to Wise Buys.
Roseville City Council Blasted by Police and Firefighters UnionsROSEVILLE, CA - International Association of Fire Fighters Local 1592, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 1245, International Union of Operating Engineers Local 39, Roseville Police Officers' Association and Roseville Police Association
Child Support Awareness Month in Placer CountyPlacer County Department of Child Support Services is taking its show on the road this month in recognition of Child Support Awareness Month
Roseville Celebrates National Night Out TonightOn Tuesday, August 4, neighborhoods throughout the City of Roseville are invited to join forces with thousands of communities nationwide
California Statewide Fire Summary (8.3.15)California Fire Updates 2015: There are 21 active fires across California, well over 9,000 firefighters battling them
Roseville Police Make Arrest in Parking Lot Robbery CaseRoseville detectives have identified all five people involved in the robbery of a woman in a parking lot last week.
Hyundai Elantra Hatchback: Affordable, stylish, roomyThe 2015 Hyundai Elantra GT hatchback certainly belongs in the discussion when car shoppers are out there searching for that just-right hatchback.
Roseville Gas Prices Drop: Find the Best Deals HereGas prices in Roseville have eased slightly this past week and industry professionals are expecting gas prices to continue a downward push
Blind Attorney Becomes National AdvocateBlind from birth, Chris Danielson is director of public relations for the 50,000-member National Federation of the Blind
Rocklin Crime Report Digest Update (8-1-15)Weekly crime report digest report update from Rocklin PD
California Fires Update Summary (8.1.15)California Fire Updates 2015: Nearly 9,000 firefighters are battling 24 large fires across California
Tahoe Restoration Act of 2015 IntroducedCongressman Tom McClintock (R-CA) and Congressman Mark Amodei (R-NV) introduced legislation to address catastrophic wildfire and invasive species threats
NEWS: In Case You Missed It