Yellow Pages |   News Updates |   Events Calendar |   Movie Times | Recycling  |   Document Shredding
Rocklin & Roseville Today Events
Celebrating Life...
HOME

Congressman Tom McClintock Remarks on Ben Franklin's Wisdom




Congressman McClintock recently delivered the following remarks on the House floor:

Ben Franklin's Wisdom

April 5, 2017
Mr. Speaker:

Congress is fundamentally a deliberative institution.  Deliberations take time and they're often messy - in fact, the bigger the issue, the messier the deliberations.  The designers of our Constitution wanted a great, big, ugly debate whenever a decision was being made.  They wanted the subject to be held up to every conceivable light and for every voice in the country to be heard.

That is certainly true of the effort to replace the collapsing bureaucracy of Obamacare with the patient-centered marketplace we have long promised.  Those deliberations must continue until they bear fruit, because there is no excuse for failure. 

Obamacare is only getting worse.  Last year's average 25 percent premium increase is likely to be followed by even bigger increases this year.  The flight of health care providers from the system is only going to accelerate.  The rapid expansion of Medicaid - which could exceed spending on defense by next year - is not only fiscally unsustainable - it doesn't even guarantee care.

Dwindling Medicaid providers and lengthening waiting lists means that many Medicaid patients have no recourse but to flood emergency rooms.  The original Medicaid population - the elderly, blind and disabled - who are only reimbursed an average of 57 cents on the dollar, are pushed to the back of every line by able-bodied Obamacare expansion patients who are reimbursed at 90 percent.

The American Health Care Act is far from perfect.  I had argued vigorously for a comprehensive bill rather than our current piece-meal approach.  I lost that debate, but I haven't lost sight of the ultimate goal: to restore our healthcare system as the best in the world.  I could list a lot of other things that could be made better in the current bill - and perhaps in our extended deliberations they will.

But those who expect perfection in our legislation fundamentally misunderstand our system.  Congress was never designed to make perfect law.  It was designed to make the best law that is acceptable to the most people.  And it's pretty good at that, when we let it be.

When the Constitutional Convention seemed hopelessly deadlocked, Benjamin Franklin declared that he didn't entirely approve of the Constitution, but he had learned over the years to doubt a little of his own infallibility, and to recognize the limitations of making decisions with others.  He noted that when you assemble a group of people to benefit from their collective wisdom, you also had to accept their collective shortcomings, and realize that a perfect product is never possible from such a process.

In another speech, he recalled as an apprentice tradesman, trying to fit together two pieces of wood.  It was often necessary, he said, to shave a little from one and a little from the other until "you had a joint that would hold together for centuries."  In this same manner, he urged them to "each join together and each part with some of our demands."

Compromise is not an end in itself.  It is a means to an end.  As long as that end moves us forward toward better policy, more freedom, greater prosperity and stronger security, whatever imperfections the measure may include are often precisely what are required to bring it to fruition.

I fear we are losing sight of these simple truths.  Ironically, factions within the House who are the most adamant in opposing Obamacare have become, as a practical matter, its most effective defenders.   I know they don't intend this to be, but the reality is that Obamacare survives today solely because of their actions in this House.

Benjamin Franklin was right.  In deliberations of this magnitude, it is essential that we each doubt a little of our own infallibility, that we each part with a few of our own demands, in order to join together and produce the reforms our country depends on us to enact.

A political minority doesn't need to compromise - it has the luxury of standing solely on principle.  But the majority, entrusted with making the actual decisions to guide our country to better days, must compromise if it is to make law that will hold together for the centuries.

Lincoln once reminded Congress that we can succeed only by concert.  He said, "It is not 'can any of us imagine better,' but 'can we all do better.'"  He urged us to rise with the occasion, to disenthrall ourselves - for only then could we save our country.

I hope some of our colleagues will consider this advice during the Easter recess.





Placer County News Headlines

13 Locations in Placer County for Free Medication Take-back Roseville, CA- A free medication take-back event will take place at 13 locations throughout Placer County on Saturday, Oct. 28.

Roseville Flash Crime Report (10.20.17)Roseville, CA - Digest summary update of Roseville Police activity through October 17, 2017.

Worst of Humanity: Arrests as FBI Targets Underage Human TraffickingSacramento - The Federal Bureau of Investigation, along with the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC), announced that 84 minors were recovered and 120 traffickers were arrested

Wildfires are Increasing Housing CrunchSacramento area Realtor, Julie Jalone of MagnumOne Realty in Roseville, writes about the wine country wildfires and how they are impacting the housing crunch and the displaced homeowners.

Sierra College Holds People & Culture Days CelebrationRocklin, CA - Have you sampled homemade tamales? Have you danced to Greek music? Can you make a Japanese origami crane?

Traffic Alert: Closure of I-80 and Hwy 65 Interchange ScheduledRoseville/ Rocklin, CA - On Saturday, October 21 from 11:00 p.m. to Sunday, October 22 at 6:00 a.m., PG&E will relocate three lines over Highway 65 between I-80 and Galleria Boulevard/Stanford Ranch Road,

Golden 1 Center Creates Economic Spark for SacramentoSacramento, Calif. - Downtown Sacramento Partnership and the Greater Sacramento Economic Council today unveiled new research explaining indicators that show the unprecedented change

California Fire Death Toll Hits 41California Fire Updates 2017: In the past week, over 245,000 acres have burned across California. More than 11,000 firefighters continue making progress on 12 large wildfires burning in the State

Volkswagen unveils versatile new GolfRoseville, CA,- The all-new 2017 Volkswagen Golf Alltrack. Volkswagen has attempted to build the Alltrack with some enviable features that give it the versatility that appeals to people who enjoy staying active.

Roseville Gas Prices Continue DroppingRoseville, CA, - More good news for Roseville area motorists as gas prices continue to move lower. The cooler weather is moving in and autumn weekday road trips are idyllic

31 Confirmed Dead in California Wildfire DevastationCalifornia Fire Updates 2017: The death toll has risen to 31 across 4 fires as estimates remain that 3,500 homes and other structures have been destroyed

Placer Women's Retreat in Roseville on November 4thRoseville, CA- The Placer Women's Retreat will take place at the Falls Event Center in Roseville on November 4, 2017.


NEWS: In Case You Missed It